Ohio State’s CFP Hopes Are Dead After Shocking Loss to Nebraska
A 31-28 loss to Nebraska ended Ohio State's College Football Playoff chances and left the Buckeyes with their most disappointing season of the CFP era. The defense was dominated up front, the backup quarterback struggled, and now only The Game remains.
Ohio State’s College Football Playoff season is over, finished off by a 31-28 loss to Nebraska on Saturday.
The defeat was the Buckeyes’ fourth of the regular season, the first time Ohio State has lost that many games in 15 years. They entered the game having already dropped three, with their playoff path barely alive. Now that path is closed. What remains is a rivalry game against Michigan next week and a season that, by any measure applied to a program of this stature, has been a disaster.
Nebraska had lost 31 consecutive games against AP Top 25 opponents before Saturday. Head coach Matt Rhule had overseen 21 of those defeats, and according to FOX Sports' reporting, the last top-25 team he beat as a head coach was Navy, a full decade ago when he was at Temple. The Cornhuskers snapped all of it in one afternoon.
What made the loss worse than the result itself was how it happened. Nebraska didn’t steal this one on a lucky bounce or a controversial call. The Cornhuskers ran the ball directly at Ohio State’s defensive line, over and over, and the Buckeyes simply couldn’t stop them. Quarterback Anthony Colandrea and running back Jamal Rule gashed the defense on the ground, particularly in short-yardage situations where everyone in the building knew the run was coming. Ohio State defensive coordinator Matt Patricia’s unit had no answer.
When Ryan Day was asked whether he still trusted Patricia to put together a workable game plan for the Michigan matchup, his answer carried the weight of a man with very few options left.
“We don’t have a choice,” Day said. “We’ve got to get this thing together in the next week to go win this game and that’s important. It’s hard to be thinking about that right now, coming off the field like this as disappointed and frustrated as we all are.”
The offense wasn’t much of a lifeline either. Starting quarterback Julian Sayin missed his fourth straight game with a shoulder injury, leaving true freshman Luke Fahey to run the show. Fahey threw for 259 yards, but 165 of those went to wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, which tells you most of what you need to know about how limited the passing attack was. The running game produced just 76 yards on 22 carries, a 3.5 yards-per-carry average that won’t scare anyone.
Smith’s presence is the cruelest part of this whole story. Ohio State had the best player in college football on the roster, was ranked No. 1 in the country at one point this season, and will not play a single snap in the College Football Playoff. For a program that treats Big Ten dominance as a baseline expectation, that’s not just a bad season. It’s the kind of outcome people in Columbus are going to be talking about for a long time.
The Game against Michigan is next. It won’t carry the same weight it has in recent years, with neither program in serious playoff contention, but Ohio State doesn’t get to treat it like a throwaway. Nobody in that building will, and Ryan Day knows it.



