CFP Committee Is Favoring the Sec More Than Ever, and It’s Not Close
The CFP selection committee has boosted SEC teams a combined 41 spots above their AP Poll positions through three rankings, the largest margin since the rankings began in 2014. Meanwhile, the Big Ten and ACC are sitting at all-time lows against the AP.
South Carolina coach Shane Beamer didn’t watch Tuesday night’s CFP rankings, so his son had to deliver the news when he got home late. The Gamecocks were still ranked, sitting at No. 21 despite a 34-6 demolition at the hands of a one-win Arkansas team three days earlier. That loss knocked them straight out of the AP Top 25, but the CFP selection committee barely flinched, sliding them four spots.
“I appreciate the committee, you know, feeling that way about us,” Beamer said Wednesday on the SEC’s weekly coaches teleconference. “I appreciate the committee respecting what it means to be in this conference.” That respect, it turns out, has never been more quantifiable or more tilted in one direction.
Add up how far the committee has placed each conference’s teams above or below the AP Poll across the first three rankings of the season, and the SEC comes out a combined 41 spots ahead. According to CBS Sports, the CFP committee’s SEC favoritism has never been greater since the rankings launched in 2014, surpassing the previous record of 34 spots set in 2018. Last season, through the same three-week window, that number was minus-10 for the SEC. The turnaround is stunning.
The timing lines up with the SEC’s move to a nine-game conference schedule this fall and the introduction of what the committee calls the Strength of Conference Enhancement, a tool designed to compare teams within the same league rather than hand one conference a blanket advantage over others. Commissioner Greg Sankey had pushed for this framework when the SEC voted in August 2025 to add that ninth game, and Missouri’s Eli Drinkwitz had publicly doubted it would materialize. Sankey was right. Drinkwitz was eating crow before Thanksgiving.
The side effects are hard to ignore. The Big Ten is down five spots overall against the AP through three weeks, its lowest mark ever. The ACC is down a cumulative 11. The committee has not placed a single ACC team above its AP position all season. Notre Dame sits a combined 12 spots lower than its AP ranking, also an all-time low. Boise State is 14 slots below its AP position. Meanwhile, four SEC teams with four losses each occupy spots 21 through 25 in the CFP rankings, four 6-4 programs ranked simultaneously in the top 25, the most ever at this stage. The previous record was two, from separate conferences. Liberty is 9-1 and unranked by the committee. Memphis is 8-2 and also absent.
The Alabama-Tennessee situation is where the logic gets hardest to defend. Tennessee beat Alabama 26-10 in Knoxville, holding the Tide to 201 yards and forcing four turnovers. Both teams are 8-2. The AP has them two spots apart. The committee ranks Alabama at No. 3 and Tennessee at No. 9. CFP chairman Hunter Yurachek pointed to Alabama’s offensive profile and called them “one of the best three or four teams in the country” on film. What he did not explain was how the strength-of-conference enhancement accounts for a six-spot gap between two teams from the same league with the same record when one beat the other by 16.
CFP executive director Rich Clark acknowledged on Tuesday that the committee is not sharing the underlying data publicly. “Basically there’s so many metrics, to really give that out publicly with an explanation of them isn’t really feasible now,” Clark said, adding that greater transparency is being explored for future seasons. That is not a satisfying answer when four-loss teams are sitting above nine-win programs right now.
There is real on-field evidence supporting the SEC’s elite programs. The conference is 10-2 against power-conference opponents and Notre Dame in nonconference play, the best mark at this point in any CFP era season. The Big Ten is 4-10 in that same window, its worst ever. Texas’s fourth-quarter comeback against Ohio State stands as the most resonant example. “We’ve played six ranked teams at this point in the season,” Texas A&M coach Mike Elko said. “And this is a league that punishes you severely if you don’t get it right.” Fair point. But that argument carries the SEC’s contenders. It does not carry a team that just lost by 28 to a one-win program. On Saturdays in the SEC, it means more. On Tuesday nights lately, an SEC loss has never meant less.



