Ridiculous: CFP Committee Just Made A Joke Of Itself With Latest Rankings
The College Football Playoff selection committee drew widespread outrage after dropping defending champion Indiana five spots during a bye week, then leaving Alabama at No. 3 despite all five of its SEC opponents losing, several badly.
The CFP selection committee dropped defending national champion Indiana five spots during a bye week. That sentence should not be possible, and yet here we are.
Indiana entered the second week of CFP rankings at No. 4. They did not play. They did not lose. They sat at home, and when the next poll dropped, they were No. 9. Committee chair Hunter Yurachek stepped in front of a microphone and explained why, which somehow made everything worse.
“Indiana was probably a victim of having a bye week at the wrong time with seven games between Top 25 teams,” Yurachek said. He also pointed to the fact that Indiana’s Big Ten opponents all lost that week, hurting the team’s perceived strength of schedule. Fine. Debatable, but fine. If that is the standard, the standard needs to be applied to every team, every week, without exception.
It was not.
Alabama sat at No. 3 heading into this week’s release. All five of the Tide’s SEC wins also lost over the past week, some of them in genuinely ugly fashion. Kentucky has dropped two straight. Mississippi State is below .500 and giving up an average of 35 points per game over a five-game losing streak. South Carolina lost by 28 to an Arkansas team the committee itself does not respect. Texas A&M ranks 13 spots behind North Dakota State in SP+ ratings. By every measure, Alabama’s résumé got worse.
Alabama stayed at No. 3. Indiana, after beating No. 18 USC, moved up one spot to No. 8.
When ESPN’s Rece Davis asked Yurachek about the obvious contradiction, the chair offered this explanation: “Alabama faced a similar circumstance where five of their SEC opponents all lost, but it didn’t have the same impact on their strength of schedule that it had on Indiana’s strength of schedule. Actually, it is very minimal for Alabama because of the quality and the strength of schedule of those five teams that lost.”
The same teams that hurt Indiana’s strength of schedule did not hurt Alabama’s. Same week. Same results. Different rules, depending on which team you’re talking about. The committee also credited Alabama for grinding out a 21-6 win at Vanderbilt, a team that is 1-6 in conference play, despite the Tide averaging 3.5 yards per play outside of three big plays. Yurachek called it a credit to Alabama for “finding a way to win” after a big game the previous week. That standard, naturally, was not extended to Indiana.
The pattern goes beyond just these two teams. The committee ranked four teams with four losses inside this week’s top 25. All four play in the SEC. When No. 1 Miami lost on the road to a top-10 Notre Dame squad by one possession, without their best player, on a contested incomplete pass call, the committee dropped them six spots. South Carolina lost to Arkansas by 28 and fell just four spots.
As analyst Joel Klatt put it, someone needs to “take the crayons away” from this group. Week after week, the CFP selection committee’s process circles back to the same destination regardless of what the results actually show. The SEC gets the benefit of every doubt, losses included, while teams outside the conference are penalized for things like, apparently, not playing football.
Indiana is the defending national champion. They beat a ranked team this week. They are sitting behind a two-loss Alabama team whose strength of schedule, by the committee’s own stated logic, just took a significant hit. The committee had every opportunity to apply its stated standard consistently and demonstrate it was operating in good faith. It chose not to, and Hunter Yurachek explained exactly why on national television.



